A Different Perspective
Guest
Column
Friday, July 4, 2003
By
Doug Jolley |
|
Doug Jolley, a Columbia,
SC, business executive and former newspaper editor, is an alumnus of
the University of South Carolina. He has strong roots in Eastern N.C.
and an enduring interest in the ECU Pirates. He can be contacted at
[email protected]. |
Realigning with class
©2003 Bonesville.net
The Atlantic Coast Conference has shown how it should not be
done. It's time now to show there still can be collegiality in college
athletics, that gentlemen and ladies can work out their differences to
mutually agreeable results.
It’s just too bad it didn’t happen first in that southern
state of North Carolina, where most folks still pride themselves on their
genteel manners and polite way of life.
It may be up to a brusque Yankee to show them how.
Big East commissioner Michael Tranghese said the Big East
would use a markedly different approach in issuing invitations compared to
the ACC, which contacted individual schools before notifying the Big East.
Tranghese has said he has already spoken to the heads of the
other conference most likely to be affected by the domino effect of
realignment, Conference-USA commissioner Britton Bannowsky and Atlantic-10
commissioner Linda Bruno.
"We're talking about a process, and I've given them both my
word that they won't be blindsided.” Tranghese said. “When we arrive at a
decision, we will share it with them before we approach schools.”
He should take it one step farther – sit down with them and
work out realigning their respective conference memberships in a way that
benefits all of them.
The die is cast. The BCS system may not survive. We, the
fans, may finally get a playoff system for the biggest and best college
football teams in the land. But no matter what major changes may take place
in the future, a two-division conference with a football conference
championship is the cornerstone for football success.
The SEC and the Big 12 made it happen, the ACC is on the
road, with the PAC 10 and Big 10 likely to follow. The only question left is
will the 12-team rule remain as a requirement for a championship game. I
think it should.
So the challenge that remains for the best 12 football teams
east of the Mississippi that are not currently in the SEC or ACC is to take
advantage of the opportunity before them and create another all-sports
super-conference of their own. If those football schools want to be in or
remain at the top tier of college football, they must achieve the two goals
now established for super-conference prosperity and national recognition: a
conference championship game in football, followed by one or more BCS bids.
The Big East should end where it began – as a superb
basketball conference. The irony is that if the three commissioners did sit
down and work it out, it probably wouldn’t be called the Big East. The only
thing currently tying the conference to football after it lost two football
versions of “Beasts of the East” is its tenuous hold on a BCS slot. Therein
lies its only advantage over C-USA and the other conferences sure to be
affected by the big-time dominoes game started by the ACC. So a reworked
football conference coming out of such a meeting would probably be called
the Big East.
The remaining non-football schools would be a
super-basketball league — call it Conference USA. If Tranghese is serious
about wanting to show the ACC how to realign in a classy manner, he should
gracefully allow the basketball members of the Big East to depart without
penalty, and accept in return those C-USA members best suited for a football
league.
A new basketball conference could include 16 teams, a great
number for a two-division basketball conference that cuts down on travel
expenses, and the ideal number for a basketball tournament. Charlotte,
Dayton, DePaul, Georgetown, Marquette, Notre Dame, Providence, Rutgers, St.
Johns, Saint Louis, Seton Hall, Syracuse, Temple, Villanova, UAB, and Xavier
would be an incredible hardwood conference.
The addition of a 12th team to the ACC and the lifespan of a
lawsuit going nowhere stand in the way of a quick and clean realignment
process. If Notre Dame does not make the ACC’s fondest wishes a reality,
then it probably comes down to whether the East Carolina advocates in the
North Carolina legislature can do for ECU what the Virginia politicians did
for Virginia Tech. If that also unlikely scenario does not pan out, then
Louisville is most likely to get the invitation for the 12th spot in the
ACC.
Assuming Louisville’s new home is in the ACC, the five
remaining Big East football schools are Boston College, Connecticut,
Pittsburgh, Syracuse, and West Virginia. Add to that the five strongest
C-USA football schools — in alphabetical order, Cincinnati, East Carolina,
Memphis, South Florida, and Southern Miss.
Unfortunately, the Mid-American conference stands to lose
its two best football schools in the Big East’s bid to make a
super-conference. Central Florida deserves a slot in a major conference, as
does Marshall. Those two schools' conference affiliation is the only piece
lacking in their becoming the major programs they have worked hard to
become. Look what the Big East did for Virginia Tech, and the SEC did for
South Carolina.
UCF and Marshall also both happen to fit in the footprint of
a conference that by necessity is already stretched from New England to
Florida.
A conference with its eyes on the next 25 years, not just
the next 5-year television contract, will recognize the wisdom of including
the less popular choices among these teams. If Louisville leaves C-USA, the
WAC is expected to invite Houston, Tulane, and Texas Christian, which are
much better fits there anyway.
There will be teams left on the outside looking in during
the process. It's unavoidable. But by creating the best basketball-only
league and creating a new 12-team all-sports super conference, what is in
the best interest of the two new leagues will be served.
It can be accomplished with class. There is incredible
synergy when all the members of an organization have a united vision with
laser focus on their shared objective. Both of the new leagues would.
Send an e-mail message to
Doug Jolley.
Click here to dig into the archives of all Bonesville
columnists.
02/23/2007 09:39:19 AM
----- |