Bonesville: The Authoritative Independent Voice of East Carolina
Daily News & Features from East Carolina, Conference USA and Beyond

Mobile Alpha Roundup Daily Beat Recruiting The Seasons Multimedia Historical Data Pirate Time Machine SportByte™ Weather





Put your ad message in front of 1,000's and 1,000's of Pirate fans. Call 252.637.2944 for flexible options & rates.





View from the 'ville
Thursday, January 10, 2008

By Al Myatt

Credibility kaput for BCS title scheme

By Al Myatt
All rights reserved.

If you put a level on the playing field in the Bowl Subdivision of college football, it appears that the bubbles don't line up quite evenly with the lines.

The USA Today Top 25 coaches poll came out shortly after LSU's 38-24 win over Ohio State in the Sugar Bowl in New Orleans, which, of course, is in the Tigers' home state. It's the second time this decade that LSU has played for — and won — a national title in front of its home folks in the Big Easy.

The Tigers are a strong and talented program but would they do what they've done in Los Angeles or Columbus, Ohio? It's doubtful considering they stumbled in Lexington, KY, and even in Baton Rouge this past season.

Championship teams are generally considered to come through in the clutch. The Tigers lost to lesser opponents twice in triple overtime.

LSU's national championship was a triumphant occasion for the Southeastern Conference, which celebrates its 75th anniversary this year. Yes, 75 years, a span which the Fox network seemingly attempted to approach with the duration of commercial breaks during its bowl coverage.

The challenge of maintaining rhythm or momentum during those lengthy commercial interludes would seem staggering.

It appears that a number of things can be learned from the rankings.

The first is that it is possible to win a national championship with two losses to teams that didn't even finish in the coaches' Top 25.

LSU may be the team that the coaches would least like to play, but the Tigers failed to perform up to their potential in their two losses. In many seasons, just one such letdown would eliminate a team from championship consideration. But this was a year that Sugar Bowl berths were lost instead of being won. Team after team was pulled out of position for the title matchup by upsets. It was a season that cried out for a playoff amid the calamity of change atop the BCS standings.

It's worth noting that the top six teams in the final poll each had two losses and the highest-ranked one-loss team, No. 7 Kansas, lost its only game to a Top 10 team, No. 8 Oklahoma.

East Carolina beat Boise State 41-38 in the Hawaii Bowl and yet the Broncos received votes in the final poll. The Pirates did not.

This commentary isn't so much about the rankings of the teams as it is about the system that gives the polls so much weight. If all the conference champions went into a playoff within the structure of the current top level bowls, much of the second guessing about the polls and their apparent contradictions would be eliminated.

The final poll indicates that perception can be more important than results in rating teams. It allows us to overlook the fact that the Tigers had two defeats from teams with a total of 10 losses between them. The bowl system is entrenched in the culture of big time college football and will not change drastically in the near future, according to the powers that be.

That's a shame. For the time being, the only true national college football champions are programs such as Appalachian State. The Mountaineers won the aptly-named Championship Subdivision on the field in a playoff — the manner in which champions should be determined. It works in NCAA Divisions II and III as well.

In a playoff system, perceptions and politics are minimized. Results on the field determine the winners. That's how it should be.

Memphis on a roll

Memphis is the consensus No. 2 pick in the college basketball polls at the moment and the Tigers don't have to worry about where they end up in the rankings in order to have their chance at playing for the national title.

College basketball gets it in terms of determining a national champion and how to market the process.

East Carolina started its Conference USA schedule at the FedEx Forum on Wednesday night where the host Tigers had won 40 consecutive games. Make that 41 as Memphis eventually overwhelmed the Pirates, 99-58. The Tigers have won 24 straight C-USA games.

ECU stayed close for much of the first half as Memphis held a relatively-scant 25-20 lead with just 5:50 left in the first half.

"They came out of the gate like Ohio State against LSU," said Memphis coach John Calipari of the Pirates.

ECU coach Mack McCarthy got the gate with 12:15 remaining after getting two technical fouls in the midst of a Memphis parade to the free throw line. The Tigers were awarded 49 foul shots as they improved to 14-0.

"We took some things away early," McCarthy said. "We mixed things up and gave them some different looks. Then they just didn't care what we were in. They were driving it and going to the foul line."

Memphis' depth also was a significant factor as it extended its lead throughout the second half to the final 41-point margin.

"They've got a lot of weapons," McCarthy said. "Their numbers are not really indicative of what they're capable of because some of their guys are getting limited minutes."

Key baseball transfers

The unseasonably warm weather this week may have folks thinking ahead to the start of baseball practice on Feb. 1 and the season opener at South Carolina on Feb. 22, part of a three-game series with the Gamecocks and a rematch of the 2004 Super Regional in Columbia.

Two transfers should benefit the East Carolina pitching staff, which will likely feature proven veteran T.J. Hose as the Friday starter. The Pirates are expected to have southpaw Matt Cox from North Carolina and Justin Bristow from Auburn in the mix behind Hose.

"He's a big (6-foot-2, 200 pounds), strong left-handed pitcher," said ECU coach Billy Godwin of Cox. "He's got velocity in the upper 80s to low 90s (mph)."

Cox played on the high school level at West Brunswick. He was 2-0 with a 5.56 earned run average in 11 1/3 innings for the Tar Heels' College World Series runner-up club last season. He had 22 appearances out of the bullpen.

Godwin also expects a boost from the versatile Bristow, a right-hander who is 6-4 and weighs 220. He was rated the third top prospect in the country out of high school in Richmond, VA, where he was a three-time all-state selection.

Bristow started 52 games at shortstop for Auburn in 2006 and hit .255 with eight doubles and 13 RBI's. He hit .362 against lefthanders. He was used primarily as a pitcher last season for a 31-25 Auburn club, going 1-6 with a 9.30 ERA. He made four starts on the mound with 25 strikeouts in 30 innings.

"We think he could be a great two-way guy for us," Godwin said of Bristow. "Maybe a Sunday-type starter and a guy who can step out there on Friday and Saturday and play a position and hit in the middle of our lineup."

Send an e-mail message to Al Myatt.

Dig into Al Myatt's Bonesville archives.

01/10/2008 03:52:04 AM


©2001-2002-2003-2004-2005-2006-2007-2008-2009-2010-2011-2012-2013 All rights reserved.
Articles, logos, graphics, photos, audio files, video files and other content originated on this site are the proprietary property of
None of the articles, logos, graphics, photos, audio files, video files or other content originated on this site may be reproduced without written permission.
This site is not affiliated with East Carolina University. View's Privacy Policy. Advertising contact: 252-349-3280; Editorial contact:; 252-444-1905.