Good riddance? If only those were the appropriate parting words for
Conference USA's exiting members.
If that were the case, next week's gathering of C-USA players and coaches
in Memphis might have a totally different feel. Instead of a Shakespearean
ending, perhaps we would witness the turning of a new, more prosperous
chapter in the league's gridiron history.
But that opportunity was lost when Cincinnati, Louisville, South Florida,
and Texas Christian decided to bolt for new neighborhoods after the upcoming
season.
There is a positive slant to the final year of the league's current
configuration: As C-USA edges closer to implosion, it should do so with a
bang.
This should have been the year when C-USA finally made a permanent move
up a rung on the pigskin pecking order. Top to bottom, this fall should
prove to be the strongest showing ever for a league that long has tried to
carve a reputable niche on the major college scene.
For starters, four C-USA clubs — Memphis, Louisville, TCU, and Southern
Miss — have legitimate Top 25 credentials. Add to them another handful of
programs that could enter the postseason conversation and C-USA should
overtake the Big East in the league power rankings.
My guess is the conference race will capture more media attention than
the Mid-American demanded last fall. With a talent pool far deeper than the
MAC, C-USA is in a position to become the darling of ESPN's talking heads in
2004.
Though the household names aren't aplenty, there is no shortage of
quality players with early-round NFL draft potential. From Memphis running
back DeAngelo Williams to Southern Miss linebacker Michael Boley, C-USA is
stacked with players destined to earn Sunday paychecks.
So much so that no team is likely to escape the league gauntlet with less
than two losses.
Selecting a C-USA favorite this year is like picking a puppy from a
litter. On one hand, Louisville and Memphis have enough offensive firepower
to decimate a third-world army. On the other, Southern Miss and TCU should
again boast stout defenses.
If you didn't know better, you might say C-USA is a league finally
hitting its stride in football. On the contrary, it is a conference that, in
its current configuration, is on its last leg.
In a more perfect world, C-USA commissioner Britton Banowsky convinces
the bye-bye bunch to sit tight. For ammunition, he cites the Big East's
questionable long-term status in the BCS and even tempts them with a little
expansion plan of his own.
With Army's exodus following the '04 season, Banowsky would have been in
prime position to add two more attractive programs — Marshall and Central
Florida, for example — to the remaining ten. Perhaps he even persistently
courts West Virginia and Syracuse.
But apparently neither was a part of C-USA's gameplan.
"To a certain extent, we've got to understand how the Big East is going
to go forward for us to be in a position to react," Banowsky said last
summer. "I don't think we can be in a position to pre-empt anything relative
to the Big East, and I'm not sure it would be appropriate, anyway, given
where our members are.
"We'll just have to wait and see. I think we're prepared to do what we
need to do to make the league stronger and that would include adding teams
to the conference."
Now, Banowksy best be prepared to fend off any other potential
aftershocks. Included is the possibility that C-USA loses some of its bowl
tie-ins, including its flagship game — the Autozone Liberty Bowl.
At the least, there's this season. By every measure, it is shaping up to
be the league's best.
For C-USA's sake, let's hope it isn't the peak.
With C-USA set to move to 12 schools next year, much has been speculated
about the two six-team divisions. The most popular model divides the league
regionally in an East-West format.
Central Florida, East Carolina, Marshall, Memphis, Southern Miss, and UAB
would comprise the East. Houston, Rice, SMU, Tulane, Tulsa, and UTEP are
likely to be grouped in the West.
It's hard to argue with that set-up from a geographic perspective. But
with access to the Bowl Championship Series set to become more inclusive
after next season, perhaps the league's direction setters should consider
balancing the competition instead.
By a landslide, the East is more heavily stocked with football tradition.
ECU, Marshall, and Southern Miss have deep-rooted gridiron cultures and have
enjoyed significant national exposure over the past decade — and history
suggests they won't fade away.
Add to them the recent ascension of Memphis and UCF's potential under new
coach George O'Leary, and the likelihood of any team escaping the East with
a perfect record is slim.
If C-USA is serious about making a run at BCS money, it will consider
balancing its two divisions. An easy solution would be to switch Southern
Miss and Tulane, which essentially would make little difference in terms of
geography.
Tulane president Scott Cowen is best known for his efforts to make the
BCS more inclusive. Now that schools like Tulane have gained more legitimate
access to the big ticket bowls, Cowen is shifting his focus elsewhere.
High on the agenda is academics. Cowen said recently he would like to see
the NCAA institute heavier academic restrictions on member schools, which
would include punishing programs that fail to meet a certain set of
standards.
"From day one, I have been a very strong proponent of such legislation,"
Cowen said. "I absolutely believe that a school, in the end, should only be
allowed to compete in postseason play — and I even think retain the number
of scholarships that we're allowed — if they indeed meet some standard of
the continuing eligibility of their student athletes and have some standard
around the graduation rates of their student athletes."
Back when Cowen formed the Presidential Coalition for Athletics Reform,
the reduction of Division I-A football scholarships to 65-70 also had
potential as a cause. However, Cowen said that hasn't received much
discussion.
"I haven't been privy to any conversation about that over the last year,"
he said. "The only group that I think has talked actively about it is the
Knight Commission."
Division I-A schools currently are allotted 85 scholarships.